Energize Private sector investment in solar PV faces risks
- Advertisment -

Private sector investment in solar PV faces risks

- Advertisment -


Moeketsi Thobela_SAPVIA CEO
Moeketsi Thobela

According to Eskom chairperson, Dr. Ben Ngubane, South Africa’s energy mix is expected to shift considerably towards renewables over the next two decades.

The Department of Energy, in a recently published Expression of Interest (EoI), has announced its intention to establish a 1500 MW solar power park in the Northern Cape, which is envisaged will be co-owned by the public and private sectors.

This points to a general trend towards an increased role for renewable energy in South Africa’s energy mix. From SAPVIA’s perspective, this should be in the context of a policy environment that has at least the following elements:

  • An increased – not reduced – allocation for PV and other renewable energy technologies in the revised IRP, taking into account that SAPVIA has consistently called for an allocation of 1000 MW towards solar PV. The allocation of 813 MW to solar PV as part of the fourth Bidding Window of the REIPPPP in 2015 has demonstrated adequately that this target is achievable.
  • The development of the market segment of solar PV projects in the range 5 to 60 MW, taking into account challenges experienced in the implementation of the Small IPP Programme (1 to 5 MW) and successes in the nascent roof-top (embedded) PV market segment – which has seen a number of projects that are larger than 1 MW and some that are approaching 5 MW.
  • The stalled process of creating an Independent System and Market Operator (ISMO) should be resuscitated – noting that it will be state-owned. In the interim, the transmission function within Eskom should be managed and regulated in a more transparent manner, specifically to provide confidence that the utility’s priorities in relation to the expansion of its own generation fleet do not come at the cost of the grid investments that are required for the integration of REIPP power plants.

For instance, it is becoming increasingly clear that a vibrant independent power producer (IPP) sector is not sustainable without an adequately resourced independent transmission company. This will become even more critical as options for replacing coal-generation capacity that will require phasing out from the 2020s onwards, taking into account environmental concerns and developments related to renewable energy and energy storage technologies.

South Africans know too well the effect of depending on one entity that is “too big to fail” – and we should learn from past experience. Any semblance of over-capacity in the generation sector – to an extent due to the struggling economy – should not lull South Africans into thinking our electricity supply future is secure. And putting all the eggs in one basket is definitely not an option:

Any new policy should allow for the immediate release of the Integrated Resource Plan (IRP) update for public review. The delay of the release of this critical analysis is creating a huge policy vacuum that is trying to be filled by a number of narrow agendas which have little to do with supplying this country and its citizens with the least cost and least regret mix of generation technologies.

This has to be considered in the context of the large-scale, mainly private-sector funded REIPPP process, which has been able to bring online close to 1000 MW of new solar PV generation capacity, within budget, over a period of only one year. This has been accompanied by a substantial reduction in the prices of solar PV – amounting to 76% [1] since the inception of the REIPPP process. As mentioned recently by the Minister of Energy, the total value of investments in the renewable energy sector so far is close to R200-billion, with an expectation it will increase to R255-billion by the close of the current procurement rounds.

Due to the electricity supply constraints South Africa faced in 2014 and 2015, the operational solar and wind power plants provided welcome relief to the economy, amounting to a net-benefit of R4,8-billion due to a reduction in the requirement for expensive diesel-fired plant and contribution towards curtailing load-shedding.

However, according to the Business Day newspaper edition of 21 July 2016, the Minister of Public Enterprises, Lynne Brown, has said that the REIPPP process was “reaching its limit” due to a requirement to invest in additional grid capacity to support the further integration of renewable energy power plants.

The issue of grid constraints as impediments to further progress in the REIPPPP places a question mark on the effect of recently announced funding support from a number of development banks, some of which has been earmarked for grid expansion projects to connect REIPPs. These include the German Development Bank (KfW) [2], New Development Bank (“Brics Bank”) and African Development Bank.

Furthermore, what about instances where the introduction of solar PV actually contributes towards a reduction in grid expansion requirements – for instance solar PV plants located close to a major load centre such as the Gauteng Province?

In the same Business Day publication, Eskom is reported to have taken a Board decision not to connect utility-scale renewable energy independent power producers beyond the REIPPPP Bidding Window 4.5 – which is currently underway.

Eskom Board’s decision to derail the further progress of the REIPPP process makes a mockery of the state-owned utility’s recent statement about renewable energy playing an increasing role in South Africa’s unfolding energy mix and its desire to support the sector. Unless that statement was merely aimed at positioning the utility towards potentially playing a greater role in the RE sector.

While this is certainly within the utility’s right, such a process cannot unfold effectively without addressing some key questions regarding the structure of South Africa’s electricity supply industry (ESI), as we’ll as taking into account recent experiences with power generation projects delivered outside of initial time and budget projections.

A potential damaging outcome of current discourse is the chilling effect it could have on private sector investment – not only in REIPP sector, but also in other parts of the economy. Hardly an outcome this economy requires when the outlook for South Africa’s economy looks gloomy, considering for instance the recent International Monetary Fund (IMF) forecast of the gross domestic product (GDP) dipping to 0,1% for 2016 and increasing slightly to 1% in 2017 [3]. While exogenous shocks (e.g. drought, low global economic growth, etc) have contributed to this undesirable outcome, there are local actions that must be taken to address factors that are ‘home-grown’.

Moeketsi Thobela, CEO of the South African Photovoltaic Industry Association (SAPVIA), says that the frequently repeated lamentations about the hobbling effects of a private sector “investment strike” on economic growth clearly do not apply in this instance. But could it be said that we are seeing a public sector “lock-out” of private sector investment?

As the private sector is not only willing, ready and has been able to deliver in the REIPP sector, why is the REIPPP programme said to be “reaching its limit”? If the public sector is not able to create the required grid capacity to connect new power generation plants, why is the private sector not provided an opportunity to contribute towards alleviating this constraint? It is also clear from SAPVIA’s engagement with Eskom that if a more holistic view [4] of the cost of delivering electricity would be adopted in the REIPPP process actually no grid constraints are limiting the immediate expansion of programme.

While it is proper to undertake frequent reviews of policy for efficacy, relevance and sustainability, this has to be done in a manner that engenders confidence. This also applies to the REIPP sector as much as it does any other sector that has to make investment decisions that have long-term effects. It is in this context that SAPVIA has supported the review of the REIPPPP that is currently underway, and holds strong view that the programme should proceed once the review has been completed.

Against this back-drop, the delay in releasing the revised IRP for public comment – in preparation for its promulgation – represent a cost to the economy that will be difficult to recover, if at all.

As an association that not only represents REIPPs, but also PV component manufacturers, SAPVIA increasingly finds it difficult to articulate the pain that is being inflicted on the emerging PV manufacturing sector due to the uncertain evolution of the REIPPPP and the seeming inability for all of government stakeholders to sing from the same hymn book. The negative effect on attempts to re-industrialise the South African economy and boost job-creation are all too obvious to see.

Contact Moeketsi Thobela, SAPVIA, Tel 011 214-0667, moeketsi@sapvia.co.za


[1] According  a Department of Energy media statement, released on 16 April 2015

[2] Government welcomes R4bn loan to Eskom from German Development Bank, GCIS, 9 April 2015

[3] World Economic Outlook, July 2016, International Monetary Fund

[4] Analysis for the future allocation of PV farms in South Africa, prepared for DOE & Eskom, 2015


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles

Engineers in lockdown: What are you doing?

Many engineers are at home under forced lockdown regulations. But what are they doing? Here's an opportunity to tell us and possibly win a...

Assisting a low-carbon transition in strained economic climate

The SUNREF programme has been extended to the end of November 2020, enabling even more South African businesses to access its credit facility to...

Benefits of LiFeP04 for electric forklifts

Chase Technologies is so convinced of the benefits of lithium iron phosphate (LiFePO4) batteries, that the company seeks to convert 50% of the current...

Exciting new features in recloser software upgrade

Switchgear engineering firm NOJA Power has announced the release of a new firmware upgrade package for the company's RC10 and RC15 recloser controllers. This...

How to survive the upcoming demand shock

Free webinar from the organisers of Power and Electricity World Africa. Register today. "How To Survive The Upcoming Demand Shock As Mining Operations Come Back...

Industrial power supplies with modular DIN rail mounting

Delta's Chrome series of industrial power supplies offer modular DIN rail mounting in the same dimensions and panel cut-out of standard miniature circuit breakers...

Dynamic line rating for wind farm connections

by Mike Rycroft, Now Media -  Wind farms pose a problem to the design of transmission lines, because of the wide variation in output power....

Government extends Covid-19 temporary assistance

The National Employers Association of South Africa (NEASA) reports that the government has extended the terms of the Covid-19 temporary assistance for the electrical...

Switchgear for dual supply RE connection kiosks

Noja Power has released its Dual Supply GMK. Designed to maximise renewable energy generation asset uptime, this new device provides renewable operators with an...

Webinar reminder: Tuesday 5 May 2020 at 10 AM

This is a reminder that Terrapinn's free-of-charge webinar "The Opportunity Of Peer-To-Peer Trading And Micro-generation In Africa" will begin on: Tuesday 5 May, 2020 at...

Companies need to plan for power outages after lockdown

by Nick Oosthuizen, Inframid South Africa has enjoyed a reprieve from load shedding since the nationwide lockdown began on 27 March 2020. Although the demand...

Webinar: The opportunity of peer-to-peer trading and micro-generation in Africa

Terrapinn, the organiser of the annual Power & Electricity World Africa conference and exhibition is offering free webinars. The conference and exhibition, which was...

Simplifying circuit breaker testing

Information from Lead HV  Lead HV, Hightest Technology’s sole supplier in Southern Africa, offers the company’s CIBRE-30 3-contact circuit breaker analyser. Offering fast, easy and...

Small and medium sized gas turbine generators: A growing market

by Mike Rycroft, Now Media Gas turbines used for electricity generation are generally large turbines in the hundreds of MW range, but small and medium-sized...

How to get economy back on track 

by Marinda Clack, Triple E Training As South Africans face the now extended lockdown period, currently in place to try to slow down the rate...
- Advertisement -